New Post: SPRedirectWithID not redirecting in IE10

I have the following on a custom new form:

$().SPServices.SPRedirectWithID({   
      redirectUrl: "EditForm.aspx",
      qsParamName: "ID"
});

When I go to the custom new form in the latest Chrome, it will redirect me to the appropriate Edit form (using Content Types). However, when using IE10, I am returned back to the AllItems page. I have tried debugging the page, but there are no javascript errors being thrown (which I suppose is obvious since it works fine in Chrome).

Any ideas?